| Nominate Nominated! | Baffi's Restaurant |
| Nominate Nominated! | Brooklyn Boys Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | How Ya Dough'N |
| Nominate Nominated! | Manhattan Joe's Pizzeria |
| Nominate Nominated! | Mister 01 Pizza |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pie Zano's Pizza & Pasta |
| Nominate Nominated! | Pizza Factory |
| Nominate Nominated! | Stallone's Italian Kitchen |
| Nominate Nominated! | Talia's Tuscan Table |
| Nominate Nominated! | Tomasso's Pizza & Subs |
| Nominate Nominated! | Tucci's Pizza |